Mine.

She's quite good actually...

They ALL are OP in their own regards.  Just because you don't like a certain Demigod doesn't mean they are OP.  I say they are all balanced quite well, something I wasn't expecting...then again, I'm no expert (or addict) like some...

-Phal

QoT with a minion build is better than Rook against towers, and has more staying power.

Contrary to what it says in the OP, Queen of Thorns is definitely OP - especially on Dominate - because she's darn near impossible to kill thanks to absorbing all the damage and hence can cap flags constantly and its hard to do anything about .

Not OP:  Regulus, Unclean Beast, and Rook.

UB is deff underpowered, no question about it. spit needs to be stonger, stun twice as long and he needs more dps.

k thx bye!!!

Torch Bearer can be extremely powerful, he just requires alot more management to avoid damage. Rain of Ice III is devastating to entire armies late game but Fireball definitely doesn't scale well once you start going up against higher level Demigod's. I typically stack as much +Movement items and the max out the buff just to stay from Unclean Beasts which are a TB's worst enemy.

For as long as there are people playing a game who can't accept their own failures for a lost game, there will always be the cry of OPness. Thats like online gaming 101 or something.

Totally agree, Rain is a great spell once you've hit rank 2 even cause it pretty much kills an entire non-upgraded wave (who upgrades troop like at lvl 1 anyways?). I feel fire isn't all that great though, frost nova does at range what fire nova has to do more upclose and personal. And circle of fire to me just seems like a useless spell, where I could just use Rain or Nova to do the same thing, in a much larger radius and range without putting myself in harms way.

Played QoT last night a few times and either I just don't understand her, or she's just really underpowered. She's alright for support, that shield is abusive but outside of that she doesn't seem to offer a whole lot. It could have been the team makeups, or the fact that it was an hour long game, or  just that I'm just REALLY bad with her, I just don't really see where she's better than an Oak or a Sedna instead (not referring to Pantheon mode)

Some losses are just unavoidable. depending on map/DG's and opponent strength, sometimes you're knackered right from the start and it no failure of your own play. Some DG/builds/maps are just unbeatable if your opponent plays beyond a certain skill level. Ive had games I've lost, and while not claiming I couldnt have played better, I would be prepared to claim if I had it wouldnt have made much difference to the final outcome.

2 Rooks spamming towers on prison for example is extremely hard to beat. Not impossible of course, but thats assuming a less-than-perfect opponent. Perfect play against perfect play may be a forced win. Im not sure of course, and this is just 1 example.

Queen of Thorns is basically the only demigod I play, and for a good reason, I think she' honestly the most overpowerd demigod in the game.  The problem is she's 100% reliant on teamwork and good partners, I have 1 friend I play most of the time with and we have never lost a game, played our share of good team players and other premade teams. I lose probably about half of my randomly joined custom games with her though.

Torchbearer would be my top pick for not overpowered.

Not OP: Rook, QoT, Oak, Regulus, Sedna, TB

Slightly OP: UB

OP: Erebus

Regulus seems weak in 1v1.  Try playing 1v1 Dominate on crucible.  You want to build up a killer snipe level, but there's no place to grind grunts in peace, and going head to head with UB, even early on, is hopless. 

So, while I wouldn't say that Reg is underpowered (enough with the double negatives already) his power seems to be biase toward the latter game/levels.

And that's the truth