The * next to a players name, means the they got disconnected from them game, either crash, or simply left the game.
Now from what i see, Kiser was the host right?
If the host disconnects from the game, there is a very small chance that everyone will get a loss, except for him, aka "host disconnect bug".
So what happened was that probably you werent the only one that crashed, everyone except for ZiviList and darkbaron crashed, but only the host got a win. This is a known Pantheon bug, which hasnt been fixed until now.