I think the first order of business is to take everyone from pacov's list and put them on yours.

• People in tier 1 from pacov's list put into tier 2 on yours
• People in tier 2 from pacov's list put into tier 3 on yours

than we can discuss moving them up or down.

Should have to request a game.  Then be rated on it.

That's what I think.

NT is no thank you?

I think NT is a placeholder. Pacov usually starts a thread and immediately posts NT after, to presumably hold the spot for extra space. I'm just guessing here though. If he just posted NT, that would be really ambiguous.

it's*

you're*

grammar*

Nazis*

Also, as for the whims of the committee, I think it should just be majority vote of Tier 1.5 (or whatever they are calling themselves now) players for entry into Tier 1 or Tier 1.5 or whatever.

The best way of sorting that out would be for those said players (in T1 in Pacov's thread) to post their own list like Koush did.  From there we have a framework for discussing this.  Right now all everyone is doing is making a lot of noise.

Also, from there we can maybe have some fun creating a few match ups.  I mean, that's what this is about, right? 

I haven't played with every T1 (T1 as per Pacov's thread) player enough.  But yeah, I'll contribute too and qualify where necessary if I don't have enough experience with the player in question to form a reasonable opinion.  

Everyone says the list is BS.  Well good.  Post your own.  Once we know where a few ppls opinions are at that puts us at a much better starting point.

u fools, pacov obviosly meant NO TIERS

The old thread is now closed.  I'll chime in here when I get a chance.  Thanks for getting the new list going how

I would like to play against anyone to get on the tier 2 list.  As 1. I am awesome and 2.  I am sexy.  I also have a large man part in my pants.  That  proves that 1 and 2 are both true.

The End.

I think you will fit in the number scheme.

Suggest you just think of this list as temporary.  Remember, the old list, that was used as the template, is pretty well outdated, so... we've got to get some updates going.  Really hope no one takes any offense over this simply because its old poo. 

I'd suggest the 1st task would be to remove folks that no longer play.  I always went by > 30 days = no longer playing.  I think to simplify, we should quickly added another TIER and call it unranked.  We can just drop folks in there that we haven't agreed on their placement, etc.  That way, we can add people that haven't been discussed recently or ever.  Then, as we get into discussions, we can rank those players and dump them into tiers.  And then the next step would be for individual player feedback saying "I think you guys are full of crap.  I'm better than _____."  And then we setup some sort of match and if they win, we agree we were wrong and advance them. 

thanks pacov

Imma just bring forward my short list that I created from Pacov's old thread, just cause I think it is a great starting place.

Tier 1:
Orcun

Tier 1.5:
Boxxy_Koush

Boxxy_Renz

GM-Zen_God

GM-McShane87

Boxxy_Mithrandar

RAWRRRR

Tier 2:

2nana

Pacov

Nomliarac

GM-Janook

cowbuttzex

kalelsmx

abuggeredhedgie/awuffleablehedgie

PeterDumpTruck

Tier 2.5:

Shreddy (Slowly creeping up to tier 2, I like the guy)

Magnus3333333333

DD_Karebears

Soccer-mom

NinkiCZ

The rest of you.

Also me and Ninki on the same committee? Sheesh, that is gonna be intresting, Ninki said he doesn't care about the tier system anymore so I don't know why he is on it, but then again Ninki says a lot of things so I'll let it slide.

Also I'd like to request some 2 v 2's (Me and Renz) against Zex and a partner of his choosing, why? Cause I haven't played with him in ages and I need to see if he's a badass now or what before I have an current opinion on the guy.

That's the problem I'm having Rawrrr, on the one hand most of the time he comprimises the game lol, however the guy in the right situation has tons of potential, I'm conflicted. All things considered I still feel Peter is more Tier 2 then 2.5, just cause he has the potential. But who knows, I'm still mulling it over.