Item Recipies?

I'm pretty sure that it won't be in the game.

You have to remember that GPG/Stardock are NOT making a DotA remake, they are making their own game. Sure they are borrowing some stuff from DotA, but they want it to be their own game, not DotA v.2.0

Imo the recipe system in dota is crap, it takes time and all it does is add items that you could just have buyed instantly in a normal store with the combined gold. In one sense the good part of it is that you get the upgrades from worse items until you get the big badaboom one but I really never liked having to run back and forth buying one piece at a time and finally being able to upgrade.... not to mention what a chore it is once your inventory is almost full. If anything a shop upgrading tree would be a better idea.

They have changed the storage management problem for items but I think its a nice idea although i do agree that we dont want them to make it a DotAv2.0 however something similar would be nice

there has been like 20 threads about this and it all ended up with good reasons to not implement this

Can we not bring this up again?  It's been debated far too much.  GPG and Stardock will put in recipies if they think it will improve the game.

Most of the problems you seem to have with itemx Xehr are what bring the strategy into the game.  Money management and item-buying strategies will indeed add another depth to the game.  Saying that it will turn the game into DotA 2.0 is a silly argument because is that necessarily a bad thing?  Is any first person shooter with guns just Doom?  Is any good rts just ripping Total Annihilation and Starcraft?  Are all good RPG's infringing DnD's copyrights?  Or even thee copyrights of the imaginations of children since the start of human history?  Class-action suit anyone?  (Also, DotA in the WC3 community is known as an AoS game as the idea for its "genre" was based directly on another mod called Age of Strife.  So why not just say you're borrowing some things from lots of different WC3 mods and borrow recipes from that?).

The largest point of recipes is to help upgrade cheaper items into more powerful ones without having to have 30 shops around to buy from.  DotA is extremely limited by the Warcraft 3 engine (even though the engine is powerful enough to do some impressive things, like WoW for instance), which is not nearly as much of a problem for Demigod as it was for the creators of DotA, but that doesn't mean it doesn't add depth to the game.  Rules to learn aren't a bad thing because they make it harder or more in depth, ask the guys that made SoaSE.

Another question for this thread I'd like to postulate is: If, even if it is not possible add them into the shipped version of Demigod, will it be possible to add the idea ot the editor?  I haven't read much up on the editor or how much power it will give to the users (creation of items, new Heroes, etc), but if that were possible and you just left it up to the community to implement this idea, then that is the least I ask.

If the engine DOES give the user much power over level creation and character creation, I wouldn't be surprised to see some direct DotA clones within the end of the year.  Again, not a bad thing as it will: A] bring over DotA players to make the game more populate, B] surely have the lasting appeal that DotA has given WC3 (went from being played a lot to not very much to superstar game status with worldwide tournaments and Basshunter's massacre of anything sembling rational music), C] keep the copyright to the contents of the game in the player's hands (unlike blizzard's editor which, in true blue Tyrannical fashion, gives the copyright to ANYTHING made with it directly to blizzard), and D] facilitate tournaments as it is built directly into the game.

If you got to this point, thx a bunch.

Edit: Changed the parentheses to braces because apparently B + ) = .

oh for the love of god lets just not discuss this again...

I second that motion for sure.  The topic is DEAD.  Stardock and GPG think it decreases accesssability while not really increasing strategy much.  I agree.  You don't.  Sorry.  Hopefully all the other things about this game will still make it fun for you, I know I like this game a lot and by release I may LOVE this game.

Anything that adds more depth is fine by me, and if it has been discussed before, then oh well, now its being discussed again.  Just because you and your ilk had a monopoly on the developers before me or the OP came along doesn't mean previously discussed ideas can't be brought up.

Edit:  Removed the personal attack and expletives, sorry about that Trigeminal.

I wasn't claiming this thread was dead, you were lame, or I was a god on the forums.  I was simply agreeing with what many have stated, that this is a DEAD horse.  We have talked it to death and unless something major has happened we know gpg and stardocks official response. By all means feel free to talk about this more, but my opinion is it is a waste.  I was simply stating that opinion and letting the OP knows the devs response.

I am not claiming to have a monopoly on the developers, feel free to discuss this further, but your post is WAY out of line.  No excuse to make things personal and start a flame war.  What you said was very rude and not kind or really appropriate.  I think most people on here try to play nice with one another, I think it would be a shame if that changed.

I don't like recipes. 

Sorry about that Trigeminal.  I overreacted big time, no hard feelings. 

Thank you for an apology, it is really appreciated.  I was really confused because I have answered/replied to a number of your posts.   No hard feelings, hope we can play on the same team sometime soon, nothing helps build common ground like a quality win!!!

I would not like recipies too, it would make the game more complicated, without making it really more complex, as you would be forced to buy certain items because in the end game only people with recipe-items would have a chance against other recipe-item user.