Oak gets both surge for speed and attack, AND pentitence for straight up damage increase.
Erebus does have bite though which can be a good damage increaser, and keeps him alive longer.
The real reason that Oak is the best at being a general though, is that he can maximize the strength of his spirits with 4 points in skills, while also increasing his weapon damage by up to 80 per swing. And since his other abilities, which are good by themselves, ALL synergize with minions... what is not to love?
(Well, I guess shield doesn't explicitly harmonize with spirits, but that's it.)