I think, and i would like to hear what gkrit has to say about this, that all demigods are balanced, except QoT. she really needs a buff. smth to spike a little more damage.
Other than that everything is fine, well, maybe TB could use an Auto Attack while chasing in fire mode.
But if u are going to say that erebus is OP, then what about Unclean Beasts that have 5 items for health+max ooze & max spit and they pop a sigil on top to go 9 - 10k of hp with almost as much dps as an erebus minion build? That is really unkillable 1v1. Only thing u have to do is farm to level up all the time. Every game of this kind needs strong melee heros, (demigods in this case) as well as strong support. OP
Sedna - And what about a sedna that has max heal+max pounce at level 11? she heals 1500 health and pounces for 1000 damage in 1 secong. Oh and max heal does 200 damage as well. So it is 1500 healed and 1200 damage. OP
QoT - what about when u see a qot that cant be killed? just spam shield and mulch shambler with cloak as favor item and u will never die.OP
Oak - there is so much to say about oak. 1st i can ramble about shield again which renders u invulnerable and unstunnable for 6 seconds and heals u on top of that. You can cap portals and tp safely anywhere, u can just tp away if being chased by every enemy in the game, u can never die with just 3 skills in shield ( Shield III). Surge of Faith a really great support aoe damage skill. You can just use it to flee if being chased, to help an ally flee, to farm creeps, or just spike more damage. Penitence Divine Justice.... etc etc
I can continue my boring blah blah but u get the point. Every character in the game is really good in the right hands.
Oak, Lord Erebus, Sedna , Queen of Thorns, Rook, Regulus, Unclean Beast, Torch Bearer. They are all special and very dangerous if played right. All balanced except QoT maybe, but they all have strong and weak points depending on the build u are playing. They all have counters for other certain demigod builds and they can be countered as well.