If the item is already owned or the player has no room then the item will be destroyed on pick up.
Just a small correction, if already owned it won't be destroyed, you just won't be able to pick up.
In a game couple of days ago, I did just this, thinking I'd just sold the item to buy giants.
Luckily, I got to sell my item, then pick up the dropped one, instead of it going poof for no profit 
Also note 2 limitations:
- You cannot drop an item when moving
- You cannot drop an item on cooldown. (If you're sharing locks/pots, always drop for teammate before using yourself)