Pretty much all you've done here is listed the top 4 DGs in any situation (Ereb, Oak, UB, Sedna), thrown Queen on bottom, and mix and match the remaining three. I'd exchange rook and regulus on this list, but that's just my opinion on the matter.
Of course it's going to be easier to win with the top 4. That's why they are the top 4.
IMO, the reason the top 4 are the top 4 is because of their ability to do three things: Escape, Chase, Burst.
TB can't chase (assuming you're fire), and cant escape (if you're ice). Rook has no chance of escaping a 3v1 gank (or even a 3v2 gank where he's the target). Reg has trouble escaping, though he's slightly better at this than the others with all his slow potential. Queen can't burst.
Each of the top 4 can do all of these things in one package. Sedna can Bite, has good speed, and can self heal. Oak can Penitance, Surge, and L3 shield-warp out. UB can have trouble escaping but his chase/damage potential more than make up for it (simply making you run first). Ereb has mist, batswarm, bite (plus minions).
-- Tukulis