Well...if you happen to see a player named "Boodah" ask him/her what they actually did to fix the same issue. He/she said all they did was "merge emails" and they were instantly able to get on......
I was told its a matter of "merging" the email addresses. Where this is done I'm not sure. There's a "Registrations" tab under "My Account" in this forum that shows me what game I bought (though it incorrectly says it was a digital download) that shows my CD Key (that's also a little alarming). Since I used the same email (i.e. didn't use paypal) I don't have multiple registrations for one game listed. Do you? If you do have multiple registrations for Demigod is there an option to "Merge" the
Demigod Forums